Youssef Cherif

Tunisia and Ghana: Parallel Histories, Diverging Democracies

MECAM Papers English | 2025


  • Abstract

    Ghana and Tunisia have often been framed as beacons of democracy in their respective regions. However, as Ghana’s democracy matured over decades, Tunisia’s experiment remained fragile and ultimately collapsed. This paper examines how historical trajectories, leadership choices, regional influences, and economic challenges shaped their democratic paths, offering lessons on the risks of democratic backsliding.

    • Ghana transitioned to democracy in the 1990s, a period of global democratic expansion, allowing its institutions to consolidate. Tunisia’s transition in 2011 occurred at a time of global democratic retreat, making consolidation more fragile.

    • Tunisia’s highly centralised state struggled with democratic governance, while Ghana’s weaker state and decentralised and adaptable system facilitated political accommodation and institutional endurance. Respective French and British colonial legacies made a difference, too.

    • In terms of external support, Ghana benefitted from ECOWAS’ strong democratic norms, whereas in the case of Tunisia, the Arab Maghreb Union – ECOWAS’ North African counterpart – remained politically paralysed. Tunisia’s post-2011 reliance on fragmented international aid and support created conflicting incentives, unlike Ghana’s relatively stable foreign partnerships.

    • Both countries have faced severe economic crises, fuelling public disillusionment with democracy. Tunisia’s economic crash, driven by high debt and inflation, led to democratic erosion. Ghana’s current economic instability poses a similar risk to its democratic stability.

    Recommendations

    Tunisia’s democratic failure serves as a warning to Ghana: democratic survival is never certain. Ghanaian policymakers must address institutional weaknesses, economic instability, media polarisation, and rising disillusionment to prevent democratic backsliding.


    English version: Tunisia and Ghana: Parallel Histories, Diverging Democracies

    French version: La Tunisie et le Ghana : histoires parallèles, démocraties divergentes

    Arabic version: تونس وغانا: تواريخ موازية وديمقراطيات متباعدة


    Reihe

    MECAM Papers English

    MECAM Papers French

    MECAM Papers Arabic

    Reihennummer

    17

    17

    17

    Serien-ISSN

    2751-6474

    2751-6482

    2751-6490

    Verlag

    Merian Center for Advanced Studies in the Maghreb

    Erscheinungsort

    Hamburg

    MECAM Papers English | 07.2024

    State–Society Relations and Sustainable Growth in Tunisia Post-2011

    Social actors’ representative organisations and their effective participation in decision-making should be fostered through more collaborative governance institutions. Building mutual trust between different CSOs would also help here. This would prevent favouritism and provide more beneficial input to the state, both serving to promote more inclusive and sustainable growth for Tunisia.

    MECAM Papers English | 11.2022

    Environment and Climate Change in Contemporary Arabic Dystopian Fiction

    Contemporary (predominantly post-2011) Arabic fiction exhibits a dystopian strand that projects a pessimistic view of the future. This literature has become particularly prominent not least because environmental degradation is a major problem in the Arab region.

    Ass. Prof. Dr. Teresa Pepe

    Senter for islam- og midtøstenstudier, Universiteit i Oslo

    MECAM Papers English | 02.2023

    Hand / Camera / Phone: Mobile Cameras, Migration, and Knowledge Production in Our Hands

    Mobile phones have a close relation to the hand itself, when they are used as handheld cameras, or in the way a touchscreen is operated. When mobile phone cameras are used in documentary filmmaking to tell a migrant’s story on their own terms, they offer a “hands-on” approach to digital knowledge production that incorporates not only the reality of its production but also the potential for a change of perspective.

    Benachrichtigungen

    Melden Sie sich hier für E-Mail-Benachrichtigungen zu GIGA-Aktivitäten an

    Soziale Medien

    Folgen Sie uns