Annegret Mähler

Oil in Venezuela: Triggering Violence or Ensuring Stability? A Context-sensitive Analysis of the Ambivalent Impact of Resource Abundance

GIGA Working Paper, No. 112, October 2009

Abstract
This paper studies the causal factors that make the oil‐state Venezuela, which is generally characterized by a low level of violence, an outlier among the oil countries as a whole. It applies a newly elaborated "context approach" that systematically considers domestic and international contextual factors. To test the results of the systematic analysis, two periods with a moderate increase in internal violence in Venezuela are subsequently analyzed, in the second part of the paper, from a comparative‐historical perspective.
The findings demonstrate that oil, in interaction with fluctuating non‐resource‐specific contextual conditions, has had ambiguous effects: On the one hand, oil has explicitly served as a conflict‐reducing and partly democracy‐promoting factor, principally through large‐scale socioeconomic redistribution, widespread clientelistic structures, and corruption. On the other hand, oil has triggered violence−primarily through socioeconomic causal mechanisms (central keywords: decline of oil abundance and resource management) and secondarily through the long‐term degradation of political institutions. While clientelism and corruption initially had a stabilizing effect, in the long run they exacerbated the delegitimization of the traditional political elite. Another crucial finding is that the impact and relative importance of oil with respect to the increase in violence seems to vary significantly depending on the specific subtype of violence.

GIGA-Forschung zum Thema

Related Research Tabs

Aktuelle Publikationen der AutorInnen

Annegret Mähler / Jan H. Pierskalla

Indigenous Identity, Natural Resources, and Contentious Politics in Bolivia. A Disaggregated Conflict Analysis, 2000-2011

Comparative Political Studies, 48, 2014, 301-332, 301-332

Matthias Basedau / Annegret Mähler / Miriam Shabafrouz

Drilling Deeper: A Systematic, Context-Sensitive Investigation of Causal Mechanisms in the Oil–Conflict Link

Journal of Development Studies, 50, 2014, 1, 51-63

Annegret Mähler / Gabriele Neußer / Almut Schilling-Vacaflor

Schwarzes Gold und grüne Ambitionen: Ressourcenpolitik in den Andenländern

GIGA Focus Lateinamerika, 05/2011

Annegret Mähler

An Inescapable Curse? Resource Management, Violent Conflict, and Peacebuilding in the Niger Delta

in: Päivi Lujala / Siri Aas Rustad (eds.), High-Value Natural Resources and Post-Conflict Peacebuilding, Abingdon: Earthscan, 2011

Annegret Mähler / Klaus Bodemer

Erdöl als Macht und Legitimationsressource – das Beispiel Venezuela

in: Robert Kappel / Matthias Basedau (eds.), Machtquelle Erdöl: Die Außen-, Innen- und Wirtschaftspolitik von Erdölstaaten, Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2011, 193-222