Jörg Wischermann / Bettina Bunk / Patrick Köllner / Jasmin Lorch

Do Associations Support Authoritarian Rule? Tentative Answers from Algeria, Mozambique, and Vietnam

GIGA Working Paper, No. 295, December 2016

Abstract
Whether associations help to democratise authoritarian rule or support those in power is a contested issue that so far lacks a cross‐regional perspective. Drawing on relational sociology, this paper explores the impact of state power in Algeria, Mozambique, and Vietnam on associations and vice versa. We focus on decision‐making in associations and on three policy areas – welfare policy concerning HIV/AIDS, economic policy concerning small and mediumsized enterprises, policies concerning gender equality and the rights of women and sexual minorities – to assess the relations between associations and the state’s infrastructural and discursive power. Most associations interviewed by us in the three countries accept or do not openly reject the state’s and/or the state ruling party’s various forms of interference in internal decision‐making processes. Whereas associations in Algeria and Vietnam help to maintain the state’s control through welfare provision, associations in Mozambique can weaken this form of infrastructural state power. Moreover, business and professionals’ associations in all three countries help maintain the state’s control through limited participation, i.e. another form of infrastructural state power. Finally, associations in all three countries support the state’s discourse and policies in the area of gender equality and women’s rights, though in all three countries at least some NGOs help weaken this form of state power.

GIGA-Forschung zum Thema

Related Research Tabs

GIGA AutorInnen

Dr. Jörg Wischermann ist assoziierter wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter am GIGA Institut für Asien-Studien, Hamburg. Er war akademischer Leiter des Projekts "Civil Society Organizations as Supporters of Authoritarian Rule? A Cross-Regional Comparison (Vietnam, Algeria, Mozambique)", das von der DFG gefördert wurde.

Bettina Bunk ist assoziierte wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin am GIGA Institut für Afrika-Studien und Doktorandin der Politikwissenschaften an der Universität Potsdam. Sie hat vor kurzem ihre Doktorarbeit mit dem Focus auf Governance und die Politik der lokalen Wirtschaftsentwicklung in Südafrika und Mosambique eingereicht.

Jasmin Lorch ist Research Fellow am GIGA Institut für Nahost-Studien und Lehrkraft für besondere Aufgaben an der Otto-von-Guericke-Universität Magdeburg. Sie forscht unter anderem zu zivilgesellschaftlichen Entwicklungen im Maghreb und in Asien.

Aktuelle Publikationen der AutorInnen

Jasmin Lorch

Islamization by Secular Ruling Parties: The Case of Bangladesh

Politics and Religion, online first, 2018

Marianne Beisheim / Anne Ellersiek / Jasmin Lorch

INGOs and Multi-Stakeholder Partnerships

in: Thomas Risse / Tanja A. Börzel / Anke Draude (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Governance and Limited Statehood, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018, 211-230

Jörg Wischermann / Phuong Thi Viet Dang / Adam Fforde

Vietnam: Kinderarbeit in Steinbrüchen an der Tagesordnung

in: Walter Eberlei (ed.), Grabsteine aus Kinderhand. Kinderarbeit in Steinbrüchen des globalen Südens als politische Herausforderung, Frankfurt am Main: Brandes & Apsel Verlag, 2018, 51-72

Jörg Wischermann / Bettina Bunk / Patrick Köllner / Jasmin Lorch

Do associations support authoritarian rule? Evidence from Algeria, Mozambique, and Vietnam

Journal of Civil Society, 14, 2018, 2, 95-115